
Faith's Throngs: Pilgrims are filling the Great Mosque in Mecca. (Muhannad Fala'ah/Getty Images)
I really shouldn't say here: it presumes that all readers of this blog are geographically bound to the United States, which isn't the case. I like to think that the sun never sets on readers of Middle East Issues.
But you get the point. Today marks the single-most universal American holiday of the Gregorian calendar. Those who may not celebrate Christmas or Easter or mark occasions like Veterans or Memorial Day are more likely to gather around a table today and break bread and turkey legs. It's a rite of Americanness even (if not especially) new immigrants happily devour. (July 4's Independence Day? It's more about shopping, movies and grilling than ritual.)
Islam is in many ways the definition of universalism, at least in the ideal: Muslims (on whom the sun truly never sets, though you could say that about any number of other religions) define themselves, wherever they are, through observance of the five pillars of Islam. The fifth and most visually arresting, the hajj, or pilgrimage to Mecca, began yesterday and will continue until Nov. 30. Making the pilgrimage to Mecca at least once in a lifetime is every Muslim's duty, although those who don't make it are spared the wrath of Khan: Islam is very understanding in those ways. The hajj is more of a recommendation than an absolute requirement, even if Saudi clerics like to think it's an essential (Saudi clerics and the Saudi tourism bureau have a lot in common when it comes to interpretations of Islamic duties).
The first day didn't go terribly well for many of 2 million to 3 million pilgrims expected to participate. Saudi Arabia, especially the coastal city of Jeddah, was hit by unusually torrential rains on Wednesday. At least 77 people were killed. The sun was back out today, enabling a more pleasant Tour-de-Hajj, which involves starting off with prayers in the tent cities of Mina, just east of Mecca, then walking the Plain of Arafat to the Mount of Mercy before repairing to the Plain of Muzdalifah for a night of prayer and pebble-gathering: on the third day, pilgrims return to Mina and throw their pebbles at pillars symbolizing Satanic temptations before the hajj's poster-scene--the circling, seven times, of the Kaaba inside the Grand Mosque in Mecca proper.
Overall numbers for the 2009 hajj are down this year as many would-be pilgrims, Saudi locals especially, are staying home for fear of catching the swine flu. The rains haven't helped. The Saudi Arab News put a good face on it all though, as in this but from Amjad Parker's "Hajj Reflections Day One":
It was not only the pilgrims that were in high spirits. Security forces generally maintained a calm and relaxed demeanor as they directed the river of people toward Mina. One guard, Mohammed Rashed, suggested a reason for their high spirits was down to the substantial benefits the Saudi government offers for keeping the peace during important occasions such as Haj. An amiable character, Rashed told Arab News that he had been working as an electrician and was being paid a minimal salary. He claimed the situation has changed after he switched careers.My colleague Huda, About's Islam Guide, is keeping up with the hajj and provides rich background and history on the ritual."I now get paid three times as much as in my previous job. I am also a weapons trainer and the insurance benefits are very good," he said. When asked about other reasons why he chose to join the security forces he replied: "It is my duty to serve the guests of God and help them."
See Also:

Comments
It’s unfortunate that we have thousands of articles on Google about the muslim pilgrimage to Mecca, and not one word on the fact that Mecca is the greatest center of religious bigotry and intolerance in the world today.
Christians are not allowed in Mecca. Jews are not allowed in Mecca. Buddhists are not allowed in Mecca. Atheists are not allowed in Mecca. Churches are illegal. Synagogues are illegal. Buddhist temples are illegal. Crosses are illegal. Priests are illegal. Bibles are illegal. Those who attempt to leave the muslim faith are executed by beheading.
Islam isn’t a creed of universality. It is a creed of appalling religious bigotry and hate. Religious apartheid in Mecca must be brought to an end, just like racial apartheid in South Africa.
No disagreement here Joe, except with your last paragraph. You’re confusing two issues. It’s not a creed of bigotry and hate, it’s an interpretation of Islam that is bigoted. On that score Saudi Arabia’s prohibitions in the name of Islam are indefensible, and reflect the blatant and copious bigotries of Wahhabism. The irony of the hajj in Mecca is that it is portrayed as the place where all are welcome on with equal respect to all and from all. Once you make it past that prohibitive gate, of course.
As far as I know, Mecca and Medina are the only two cities in the world banned all year round from visits by anyone but members of a single faith. They are shining beacons of religious bigotry. They are monumental symbols of despair for many people that there will be anything other than a war with these type insensitive and fanatical bigots. The mere fact of their existence should always be used to counter anyone saying that the Muslim faith is tolerant.
“Oh you who believe! Truly the idolaters are unclean; so let them not, after this year, approach the Sacred Mosque….” (9:28). Non-Muslims not allowed in Mecca/Medinah because they may not know or understand the rites of cleanliness, behavior, dress, etc. Their prohibition is as much for their protection as it is for the protection of the holy sites. Do you remember the Mohammed cartoon situation across the Middle East? If a non-Muslim went to Mecca and did something perceived as desecration even in the slightest, it would cause a huge controversy and more than likely, violence. Extremely religious people are not very rational.
You can find many examples throughout the world and throughout history of places off-limits to foreigners or the ‘uninitiated’ (The Forbidden City, Lhasa, secret societies, private clubs, many places within the former Soviet Union were/are restricted, some monasteries). Not everyone agrees with the sense of entitlement many Westerners have to travel an ‘open world’ without borders (just ask those people arrested by Iran and North Korea for illegal tresspass/spying). These travelers claim to respect other countries and cultures, but only on their own terms.
Furthermore, if you have no respect for the (”intolerant, bigoted”) Islamic faith, of which protection of Mecca/Medinah is a longstanding tradition, why would you want to visit either of those cities anyway?